After a full day of lake time, mountain air, and checking out the best things to do around Deep Creek Lake, it’s only a matter of time before your stomach starts to rumble. When hunger strikes, you don’t want to be stuck now knowing where to go!
Lucky for you, there are plenty of great dining options to choose from. Whether you want to eat dinner with the locals, find the best fine dining spot in town, or you‘re trying to find a specific kind of cuisine, we’ve put together a list of standout restaurants in Deep Creek, Maryland, to help you decide where to eat next. No more dead-end googling and searching around for the best spots; we’ve done the work for you!
Ready to find the best restaurants in Deep Creek? Fantastic!
Before we dive on into the top restaurants in town, make sure you’re signed up for Railey’s email list so you can stay up to date on our biggest updates!
In this blog:
- What Kind of Food is Deep Creek, MD Known For?
- Breakfast & Lunch Spots
- Pizzerias
- Casual Dining
- Date Night, Bars & Nightlife
- Book Your Deep Creek Stay Directly with Railey Vacations!
What Kind of Food is Deep Creek, MD Known For?
The great thing about Deep Creek is that nearly all of the restaurants are one of a kind! That means you’ll only experience their menu right here at the lake. Another unique feature is that many restaurants along the lake offer dock slips for customers – meaning you can take the boat to lunch or dinner. Many spots offer awesome outdoor dining options, some are even dog-friendly!
Keep in mind that food delivery is extremely limited in the area – most of the below restaurants do not offer delivery.
Top Restaurants in Deep Creek:
Breakfast & Lunch Spots
Whether you’re looking for a grab-and-go breakfast sandwich or l a great place to sit for a delicious lunch, these spots will check all your boxes! Find the best places for breakfast and lunch at Deep Creek, MD, below!
Black Hawk Coffee + Kitchen
1550 Deep Creek Drive McHenr,y MD 21541
Must Try Menu Item: Turkey Focaccia Sandy
New to the lake area (expanded from Oakland), this is a go-to spot! Enjoy delicious breakfast sandwiches, coffee, lattes, and lunch options. They offer a spacious indoor dining area in addition to an outdoor deck overlooking the lake.
Trader’s Coffee House
21311 Garrett Highway, Oakland, MD 21550
Must Try Menu Item: Cookies & Crème Frappe
A local favorite! Trader’s Coffee House offers an extensive drink menu, a pastry shelf full of delicious options, and a breakfast & lunch menu. With their own coffee blends rotating daily and drink menu updated seasonally, there’s always something new to try. Gluten Free and Vegan options! Accessible by Lake!
Canoe on the Run
2622 Deep Creek Drive McHenry, MD 21541
Must Try Menu Item: Breakfast Wrap
One of the hidden gems at the lake! Just off the beaten path, Canoe on the Run offers a delicious breakfast menu, incredible house-made desserts, lunch menu, and daily specials! Vegan options available!
Casselman Bakery & Café
19595 Garrett Highway, Oakland, MD 21550
Must Try Menu Item: Taco Salad (limited special) or Regular Salad Bar
Open for breakfast and lunch, The Casselman Bakery & Café offers a varied menu with something for everyone in the family. Their breakfast provides familiar favorites like sausage gravy and biscuits or breakfast sandwiches, while their lunch menu offers arguably the best salad bar in the area and a variety of delicious sandwiches and wraps. They offer daily lunch specials – you don’t want to miss their taco salad! Dog Friendly Outdoor Dining!
Espresso Alley Drive Thru
25901 Garrett Highway McHenry, MD 21541
Must Try Menu Item: Toasted Marshmallow Cold Foam on Cold Brew
On the go? Espresso Alley’s drive-thru coffee shack is the perfect place to get in and get out! Offering one of the largest drink menus in the area, there’s definitely something tasty for everyone in your group. They also offer breakfast and lunch options in addition to locally made sweets and pastries.
Firefly Farms
309 S Main Street, Accident, MD 21520
Must Try Menu Item: Cabra Classica Sandwich
A must-do for lunch! Firefly Farms is a local specialty store that makes dozens of goat and dairy cheeses. Their café offers their delicious cheeses on a variety of unique sandwiches and salads. While you wait for your food, sample their cheeses or browse their shop!
Pizzerias
Nothing beats a good pizza after a long day on the lake or the slopes! No matter what style of pizza you prefer, there are several great options sure to please the whole family. We put together our favorite pizza restaurants at Deep Creek!
Brenda’s Pizzeria
21311 Garrett Highway Oakland, MD 21550
Must Try Menu Item: Classic Cheese Pizza
Arguably the most popular pizza at the lake! Brenda’s offers traditional New York-style pizza – perfectly thin with delicious crust. In addition to the classic cheese, they have a scrumptious white pizza and several specialty pizzas to choose from. During the fall and spring seasons, pizzas are half price on Mondays! Accessible by Lake!
Mountain State Brewing Company
6690 Sang Run Rd Mchenry MD 21541
Must Try Menu Item – Fire on the Mountain Pizza
A local favorite! Not only does Mountain State brew their own beer, they make some of the best pizza in the area! Using wood-fired ovens, you get the unique flavor and texture from the fire mixed with incredible flavors. They have an incredible line-up of flatbread flavor combinations from cheeseburger to goat cheese to classic flavors. Dog FriendlyOutdoor Dining!
Deep Creek Pizza
24450 Garrett Highway McHenry, MD 21541
Must Try Menu Item: Pepperoni Pizza
Located next to Funland Arcade, Deep Creek Pizza is a hidden gem for pizza! The garlic-butter brushed crust adds the perfect flavor to complement the pizza. Their hours vary during the fall, winter, and spring – so make sure to check their Facebook page or website for current hours.
Fox’s Pizza Den
19567 Garrett Highway Oakland, MD 21550
Must Try Menu Item: Taco Pizza
One of the only pizza spots at the lake that delivers! Fox’s offers a great mix of food – but their pizza is where it’s at! Their Taco Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Pizza are local legends. They offer several different sizes, including the ‘Big Daddy’ which is large enough to feed the whole crew.
Casual Dining
UNO Pizzeria & Grille
19814 Garrett Highway Oakland, MD 21550
Must Try Menu Item: Crab Dip
UNOs (as the locals call it) is one of the hottest lake spots you’ve got to try! Their menu has a little bit of everything, from their deep dish pizza to a spicy rattlesnake pasta to soup and salad options. Perfect for lunch or a big dinner with family and friends. Accessible by Lake! Outdoor Dining! Pets permitted on Lakeside Lawn Area (not in restaurant area or outdoor seating)
Ace’s Run Restaurant & Pub
20160 Garrett Highway Oakland, MD 21550
Must Try Menu Item: Pasta Nights on Wednesday Evenings
From mouth-watering burgers to a one-of-a-kind pasta night experience, Ace’s Run has a menu like no other – plus, they update it seasonally! Every Wednesday, in addition to their full menu, Ace’s has an open front kitchen where they make you your very own pasta dish with your exact specifications. They also have gluten free options, and are a great option for outdoor dining. Aces is accessible by lake!
Dutch’s at Silver Tree
567 Glendale Rd, Oakland, MD 21550
Must Try Menu Item: Seafood or Steak!
If you’re craving a great steak, succulent seafood, or entrees you’ll never forget, Dutch’s at Silver Tree is the spot! With expansive indoor and outdoor dining options, it’s a great choice for a casual dinner or romantic evening. Their classic menu offers a large variety of seafood and steak, along with favorites like pasta, soup, and salad. If you’re dining outside at the ‘Harbor Bar’, ask for their special menu and a grapefruit or orange crush. Accessible by Lake! Pet Friendly Outdoor Dining.
Date Night, Bars & Nightlife
If you’re looking for delicious craft cocktails, small plates, or the perfect place for date night at Deep Creek, these next few recommendations are for you! Enjoy live music at many of these venues as well as outdoor seating options.
Firewater Kitchen & Bar
20128 Garrett Highway Oakland, MD 21550
Must Try Menu Item: Anything on the Cocktail Menu!
With expansive views of the water, ample indoor and outdoor seating, and a large bar, Firewater Kitchen & Bar is the perfect place to grab a drink and a bite! Their small plates menu is perfect for sharing, or try a filling and delicious entrée or sandwich! Their shining star is definitely their unique cocktail menu. No matter what you prefer, there’s a drink for you (mocktails, too!). Accessible by Lake! Outdoor Dining.
Pawn Run Kitchen & Bar
485 Boy Scout Road Oakland, MD 21550
Must Try Menu Item: Street Tacos or Honey Brussel Sprouts
Off the beaten path, Pawn Run Kitchen & Bar offers an extensive specialty cocktail menu, including NA liquors, and a delicious menu. Whether you want to split some small plates over a few drinks or enjoy a hearty meal, Pawn Run has something for everyone. Pet Friendly Outdoor Seating!
Black Bear Tavern
102 Fort Drive McHenry, MD 21541
Must Try Menu Item: The BBT Burger
A more traditional nightlife spot, Black Bear Tavern offers a classic bar menu with plenty of on-tap and ready-to-go drink options! Black Bear often has weekend events, including a mechanical bull, DJ, or live band. Centrally located in McHenry, it’s a great spot to enjoy post-skiing or a day on the water. Outdoor Seating Available!
JG’s Pub
18553 Garrett Highway Oakland, MD 21550
Must Try Menu Item: Steak Sub
A local favorite! JG’s Pub offers a traditional bar menu with some of the best subs you’ll find at the lake! From their fried zucchini planks to their larger-than-life steak sub, you won’t leave hungry, we promise!
Book Your Deep Creek Stay Directly with Railey Vacations!
7-Bed, 5.5-Bath Lakefront Vacation Rental, "Treasured Memories".
Yum! Now that you know all the best places to eat in Deep Creek, it’s time to book your trip! After all, food is one of the most exciting parts of vacation. And you’ll be eating like a local when you visit!
When it comes to the top vacation rentals in Deep Creek, you can’t beat Railey Vacations. Whether you’re searching for a dog-friendly property so you can bring your pup along or a lakefront house to take in the best views of Deep Creek Lake, we’re positive that you’ll find the perfect fit amongst our extensive catalog of properties. Ready to plan your vacation? Browse our available Deep Creek vacation rentals now, and book your trip directly with Railey Vacations!